For a common problem like a degenerative knee meniscus tear or early osteoarthritis, what factors would guide you to recommend surgery versus non-operative management?

Specialty-Specific

Purpose

This question checks how well you can weigh treatment options and make patient-centered decisions. Interviewers want to see if you understand the balance between surgery and non-surgical options while considering patient needs.

Tips

  • Discuss patient-specific factors like age, activity level, and pain severity.
  • Mention the importance of shared decision-making and patient preferences.
  • Highlight the role of evidence-based guidelines in your decision process.

Common mistakes

  • Don't oversimplify the decision by focusing on just one factor, like pain.
  • Avoid dismissing non-operative options without a solid reason.
  • Steer clear of sounding judgmental about patients' choices or compliance.